Editorial oversight for podcast teams that can't review everything
PodCritic applies consistent editorial analysis across draft and published episodes, then turns recurring evidence into clear, human-reviewed direction. It helps your team decide what to preserve, what to change and where senior editorial attention is most needed.For live production decisions, developing shows and selected podcast portfolios.
Editorial intelligence at every level
Before publication
Get a concise, human-checked editorial briefing on a draft episode before it reaches your client or audience.
Across a show
Identify recurring strengths, constraints and format drift as new episodes are published.
Across a portfolio
Give editorial leaders a consistent view of what needs attention across multiple shows, formats and producers.
Where PodCritic creates the strongest valuePodCritic is particularly useful when the work can still change or senior editorial coverage is limited. For example, draft episodes, new or evolving shows, strategic reviews and selected portfolios where leadership cannot personally review everything.Not a hosting platform. Not an editing tool. Not a dashboard of metrics.For teams accountable for editorial quality without enough time to review every episode themselves.
Senior editorial attention does not scale with your slate
Performance tools show what happened. They do not show which editorial questions deserve attention, what should be preserved or where deeper review is most needed.As a team scales, three structural problems emerge:Senior review cannot cover everything:Studio leads cannot listen to every episode in depth.Editorial decisions lack a shared evidence baseProducers bring valuable judgement, but conclusions can be difficult to compare or track consistently.Attention is not always focused where it creates most value:Flagships and urgent productions absorb review time while developing or apparently healthy shows may receive little independent scrutiny.Downloads tell you what happened. PodCritic helps you understand what to change.
Software does the recurring analysis. Humans focus where judgement matters
PodCritic consistently analyses every episode included in the service. Human editorial review is concentrated on the conclusions most likely to influence an edit, a producer conversation or a wider strategic decision.That means you receive credible editorial direction without paying someone to manually review every episode from scratch.
PodCritic analyses
Episodes, structure, pacing, clarity, format consistency and recurring editorial patterns.
Findings checked
Strategic, disputed, unusual or high-consequence conclusions receive human review.
Insights received
Briefings can be delivered through email, PDF, meetings or an agreed existing workflow. Platform access is optional.
How PodCritic Works
1. We establish context
We learn what the show is trying to achieve, who it serves and what matters editorially and commercially.
2. PodCritic analyses the work
The software reviews episodes consistently, identifies the most consequential issue and tracks recurring patterns over time.
3. Important findings are human-checked
Principal conclusions are checked against supporting episodes, relevant context, meaningful counter-evidence and performance evidence where available.
4. The direction reaches your team
Findings can be delivered by email, PDF, a review call or through an agreed existing workflow.
5. Intelligence compounds
As PodCritic reviews more episodes, it develops a stronger understanding of each show and the portfolio around it.
What a PodCritic review delivers

Episode Editorial Briefing
One clear judgement, why it matters, supporting evidence, one realistic next action and what should be preserved.
Show Intelligence
Recurring strengths, constraints, format drift and the priority for the next production period.


Portfolio-Level Direction
A leadership-ready view of which selected shows need attention, what evidence supports that priority and where deeper investigation is warranted.
Human Interpretation
Validation and strategic interpretation where findings affect talent, clients, commissioning or leadership decisions.

This isn’t analytics or AI commentary.It’s structured editorial judgement — applied consistently at scale.
Performance data shows what happened. PodCritic helps your team decide what deserves attention next.
Analytics and production tools
Downloads and engagement data
Retention charts
Editing and production workflows
Retrospective reporting
PodCritic
Structured editorial judgement
Recurring cross-episode patterns
Show and portfolio oversight
Forward-looking editorial direction
Human interpretation where it matters
Performance evidence can confirm, complicate or challenge an editorial interpretation. PodCritic turns that evidence into a clearer editorial decision.
Testimonials
“PodCritic has become a really useful editorial second opinion. It hasn't replaced my own judgement or creativity, rather it reinforces my thinking and helps highlight structural elements I could look at a bit more. This critical friend approach fits naturally into my review process and gives me practical feedback I can use throughout post-production.”Vic Elizabeth Turnbull, MIC media
How to start with PodCritic
Editorial Reviews & Audits
Independent, evidence-backed editorial assessments for individual episodes, entire shows and podcast series.Understand what's working, identify recurring editorial patterns and establish clear priorities for improvement.
Episode Editorial Briefing — £195A focused assessment of an individual episode, identifying the most consequential editorial opportunity before or after publication.
Show & Series Editorial Review — From £750A deeper assessment across multiple episodes, identifying recurring strengths, constraints and editorial priorities.Standard scope: up to 8 representative episodes. Larger or bespoke strategic assessments quoted separately.
Every review includes:
Structured editorial analysis
Human-reviewed conclusions
Supporting evidence and practical recommendations
Clear direction on what to preserve and what to improve
A concise written briefing, with a strategic walkthrough for multi-episode reviews
Ideal for producers, studios and agencies seeking an independent editorial perspective or preparing to make an important production decision.A one-off Show Review can establish your editorial baseline, which Ongoing Intelligence then builds on as new episodes are published.
Ongoing Intelligence
Consistent editorial oversight across selected shows, without requiring senior editors to review every episode themselves.
Single Show - £250/monthOne weekly show, with episode-level findings, accumulating show intelligence and a concise human-reviewed monthly synthesis.
Studio - From £500/monthTwo to five selected shows, with coverage and reporting scaled to publishing volume.
Portfolio - CustomSix or more selected shows, with cross-show intelligence, leadership priorities and agreed reporting requirements. Also includes selective investigation of the shows and findings that warrant deeper editorial attention.
Every ongoing package includes:
Ongoing episode analysis
Recurring strengths, constraints and format patterns
Human review of important conclusions
Concise monthly editorial briefings
Clear priorities for producers and leadership
Delivery through email, PDF or an agreed workflow
Available for individual shows, studios and selected podcast portfolios. Scope and pricing reflect episode volume, the number of shows and reporting requirements.
Need more strategic support?
Editorial Partner
For organisations that want help applying PodCritic's findings, not simply receiving them.A named editorial partner can work with leadership to interpret evidence, agree priorities, support editorial decision-making and develop specific recommendations for producers, hosts and formats.Editorial Partner engagements start at £2,000 per month, including agreed ongoing intelligence coverage. Human support, meeting cadence and deliverables are defined in advance.
Larger networks and enterprise
For larger networks, publishers and organisations with complex portfolios, PodCritic offers tailored intelligence coverage, executive reporting and agreed workflow integrations.Pricing depends on portfolio size, episode volume, reporting requirements and the level of human strategic support.Paid pilots are available for organisations that want to prove value against a defined editorial question before committing to an ongoing service.
FAQs
Does everyone need to use the PodCritic platform?
No. Findings can be delivered by email, PDF, review call or through an agreed workflow. Platform access is available where useful, but access is not the service.
How do you decide which shows to analyse?
Where several shows are available, we begin with an Editorial Coverage Review. We consider editorial development, existing senior coverage, current uncertainty, strategic consequence, available evidence and leadership visibility. The largest or most prestigious show is not automatically the best place to start.
Does PodCritic replace producers or editors?
No. PodCritic supports their judgement by applying a consistent framework, identifying patterns and concentrating attention on the decisions most likely to improve the work.
Does a human listen to every episode?
Not routinely. PodCritic analyses every included episode. Human review focuses on strategic conclusions, unusual findings, disputed recommendations and decisions with greater editorial or commercial consequence.
Can you review an episode before publication?
Yes. Episode Editorial Briefings are designed for draft audio, transcripts, narration and in-flight productions.
Can PodCritic use performance data?
Yes, where relevant data and definitions are available. Performance evidence may confirm, complicate or challenge an editorial interpretation. PodCritic does not replace your analytics platform or claim that performance data proves editorial causality.
Can PodCritic analyse video podcasts?
Yes. Video and cross-format analysis is available on selected engagements, with scope agreed according to format, volume and review requirements.
Does £250/month include an individually human-reviewed briefing on every episode?
No. Single Show Ongoing Intelligence analyses new episodes, tracks patterns across the show and includes a human-reviewed monthly synthesis.It does not include individually human-checked pre-publication feedback for every draft. For that, choose an Episode Editorial Briefing (£195) or a Pre-publication Briefing Pack (£650/month for up to four drafts).
What's the difference between Ongoing Intelligence and Editorial Partner?
Ongoing Intelligence identifies recurring editorial patterns, provides evidence-backed recommendations and helps your team understand where to focus attention.Editorial Partner builds on that intelligence with additional human strategic support. A named partner works with your leadership team to interpret findings, agree editorial priorities and help translate recommendations into decisions and production plans.Both include human quality checks. The difference is the level of direct editorial involvement, not the quality of the underlying analysis.
Is this consultancy or software?
Both elements are deliberately combined. PodCritic’s software performs the recurring analysis; human editorial involvement validates consequential findings, interprets patterns and helps teams apply the direction.
